Living in the Tension: Joy, Prayer, and Gratitude in a Broken World
1 Thessalonians 5:16-18
We live in a culture of disappointment.
Despite having more wealth, education, and opportunities than any generation in human history, we find ourselves perpetually dissatisfied. American author John Cheever observed that "the main emotion of the adult American who has had all the advantages of wealth, education, and culture is disappointment." We've been sold a story that everything should trend upward and to the right, that more education plus more wealth equals more happiness. Yet here we are, arguably the most privileged society in history, and we're miserable.
Into this culture of disappointment comes an ancient instruction that sounds almost absurdly simple: "Rejoice always, pray continually, give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus" (1 Thessalonians 5:16-18).
Three commands. Three adverbs. A lifetime of practice.
Despite having more wealth, education, and opportunities than any generation in human history, we find ourselves perpetually dissatisfied. American author John Cheever observed that "the main emotion of the adult American who has had all the advantages of wealth, education, and culture is disappointment." We've been sold a story that everything should trend upward and to the right, that more education plus more wealth equals more happiness. Yet here we are, arguably the most privileged society in history, and we're miserable.
Into this culture of disappointment comes an ancient instruction that sounds almost absurdly simple: "Rejoice always, pray continually, give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God's will for you in Christ Jesus" (1 Thessalonians 5:16-18).
Three commands. Three adverbs. A lifetime of practice.
The Defiant Act of Joy
The first command is to rejoice always. In Greek, the word is "chairo," which literally means "to joy." It's an active verb, not a passive emotion. This is crucial because we've been conditioned to think of joy as something that happens to us rather than something that flows through us.
We all have those moments standing at the edge of the Grand Canyon, watching a humpback whale breach, or sitting with family when everything feels right with the world. Joy seems to wash over us in those instances. But that's not the joy Paul is talking about. He's describing joy as a defiant choice, an act of spiritual rebellion against a world bent toward cynicism and despair.
Researcher Brené Brown discovered something fascinating about joy: it's the most vulnerable emotion we experience. We're so afraid of joy that when we feel it, we immediately start "dress rehearsing tragedy." A mother looks at her sleeping child, experiences a moment of pure peace, and her very next thought is often, "I hope nothing terrible happens." We can't let ourselves stay in joy because we're constantly preparing for the next disaster.
But followers of Jesus should have more capacity for joy than anyone else. Why? Because we have more faith in something beyond this broken world. We believe in a kingdom that is coming and has come, where tears will be wiped away and all things will be made right. If we don't have that hope, what are we doing? And if we don't have that hope, we'll never have joy because we'll always be afraid of what this world might do to us.
God himself is a God of joy. Dallas Willard argued that God is the most joyous being in the universe. Since God is omnipresent, he is in every beautiful moment, every stunning sunset, every burst of laughter. If God is with us in those joyful times, joy must originate from somewhere, from Someone who helps us experience it.
C.S. Lewis put it perfectly: "Joy is the serious business of heaven."
We all have those moments standing at the edge of the Grand Canyon, watching a humpback whale breach, or sitting with family when everything feels right with the world. Joy seems to wash over us in those instances. But that's not the joy Paul is talking about. He's describing joy as a defiant choice, an act of spiritual rebellion against a world bent toward cynicism and despair.
Researcher Brené Brown discovered something fascinating about joy: it's the most vulnerable emotion we experience. We're so afraid of joy that when we feel it, we immediately start "dress rehearsing tragedy." A mother looks at her sleeping child, experiences a moment of pure peace, and her very next thought is often, "I hope nothing terrible happens." We can't let ourselves stay in joy because we're constantly preparing for the next disaster.
But followers of Jesus should have more capacity for joy than anyone else. Why? Because we have more faith in something beyond this broken world. We believe in a kingdom that is coming and has come, where tears will be wiped away and all things will be made right. If we don't have that hope, what are we doing? And if we don't have that hope, we'll never have joy because we'll always be afraid of what this world might do to us.
God himself is a God of joy. Dallas Willard argued that God is the most joyous being in the universe. Since God is omnipresent, he is in every beautiful moment, every stunning sunset, every burst of laughter. If God is with us in those joyful times, joy must originate from somewhere, from Someone who helps us experience it.
C.S. Lewis put it perfectly: "Joy is the serious business of heaven."
The Continuous Conversation
The second command is to pray continually. This doesn't mean quitting your job to become a monk. It means keeping one foot on earth and one foot in the heavenly realm, maintaining an ongoing conversation with God throughout your day.
There are many forms of prayer: praise, thanksgiving, petition, intercession, lament, listening, and communion. Most of us have mastered the petition prayer, showing up with our laundry list of requests before walking out the door. But prayer is supposed to be a two-way conversation where both parties get to speak.
We've especially lost the art of lament, those angry or confused prayers where we tell God we don't understand what he's doing. We think that's disrespectful, but the Bible is full of people praying angrily at God. Even Jesus, in the garden, prayed, "If you can take this cup from me, please do it."
The Daily Office is an ancient practice that can help us pray continually. It involves setting aside multiple brief times throughout the day for prayer: at awakening, sunrise, noon, sunset, and before sleep. These aren't hour-long sessions but five or ten-minute pauses to refocus and keep ourselves in conversation with God.
The goal isn't to add more religious obligations to our calendar. The goal is to practice the presence of God, to see our daily lives through the lens of heaven rather than being trapped in the material world alone.
There are many forms of prayer: praise, thanksgiving, petition, intercession, lament, listening, and communion. Most of us have mastered the petition prayer, showing up with our laundry list of requests before walking out the door. But prayer is supposed to be a two-way conversation where both parties get to speak.
We've especially lost the art of lament, those angry or confused prayers where we tell God we don't understand what he's doing. We think that's disrespectful, but the Bible is full of people praying angrily at God. Even Jesus, in the garden, prayed, "If you can take this cup from me, please do it."
The Daily Office is an ancient practice that can help us pray continually. It involves setting aside multiple brief times throughout the day for prayer: at awakening, sunrise, noon, sunset, and before sleep. These aren't hour-long sessions but five or ten-minute pauses to refocus and keep ourselves in conversation with God.
The goal isn't to add more religious obligations to our calendar. The goal is to practice the presence of God, to see our daily lives through the lens of heaven rather than being trapped in the material world alone.
The Grateful Heart
The third command is to give thanks in all circumstances. Notice it doesn't say give thanks for all circumstances. You're not expected to thank God for genocide, cancer, or tragedy. But you can give thanks in those circumstances because there are always things to be grateful for.
Paul wrote these words to a church under massive oppression, people fearing for their lives and livelihoods because they followed Jesus instead of Caesar. If they could find things to be grateful for, so can we.
G.K. Chesterton wrote, "The test of happiness is gratitude. The moment we think we have a right to something, we become miserable."
We live in an entitled generation. Millennials were labeled "entitled," but let's be honest, the boomers were called the "me generation" first. Entitlement isn't generational; it's human.
What separates privilege from entitlement? Gratitude.
Brené Brown discovered that people who truly practice gratitude have a profound capacity for joy. They've learned that joy, not fear, is worth the risk of vulnerability.
Paul wrote these words to a church under massive oppression, people fearing for their lives and livelihoods because they followed Jesus instead of Caesar. If they could find things to be grateful for, so can we.
G.K. Chesterton wrote, "The test of happiness is gratitude. The moment we think we have a right to something, we become miserable."
We live in an entitled generation. Millennials were labeled "entitled," but let's be honest, the boomers were called the "me generation" first. Entitlement isn't generational; it's human.
What separates privilege from entitlement? Gratitude.
Brené Brown discovered that people who truly practice gratitude have a profound capacity for joy. They've learned that joy, not fear, is worth the risk of vulnerability.
Living God's Will
At the end of these three commands comes a promise: "This is God's will for you in Christ Jesus."
Many people spend enormous energy trying to discern God's will for major life decisions. Should I marry this person? Take that job? Move to this city? But God's will is already clearly laid out. It's not primarily about what you do but who you are in the process.
If you're walking in step with the Spirit, becoming a person who rejoices, prays continually, and gives thanks, the big decisions won't be that big. Why? Because you've been building the muscle all along. You've been praying about everything up to this moment, so this prayer isn't much different.
God's will isn't just for a few crucial turning points. It's for every moment, to live with him, to walk in his presence, to let his life flow through ours.
In a world drowning in disappointment, fear, and entitlement, we have the opportunity to bring the kingdom of heaven to earth. Not someday. Today. Right now, in the midst of the brokenness.
How are you doing at rejoicing always, praying continually, and giving thanks in all circumstances?
What needs to change?
Many people spend enormous energy trying to discern God's will for major life decisions. Should I marry this person? Take that job? Move to this city? But God's will is already clearly laid out. It's not primarily about what you do but who you are in the process.
If you're walking in step with the Spirit, becoming a person who rejoices, prays continually, and gives thanks, the big decisions won't be that big. Why? Because you've been building the muscle all along. You've been praying about everything up to this moment, so this prayer isn't much different.
God's will isn't just for a few crucial turning points. It's for every moment, to live with him, to walk in his presence, to let his life flow through ours.
In a world drowning in disappointment, fear, and entitlement, we have the opportunity to bring the kingdom of heaven to earth. Not someday. Today. Right now, in the midst of the brokenness.
How are you doing at rejoicing always, praying continually, and giving thanks in all circumstances?
What needs to change?
No Comments